← Skirnir Studios

The Matter of Troy in the Middle Ages

Medieval & Renaissance · a myth in 8 episodes, reconstructed from the texts

The Middle Ages read Troy not in Homer but in Dares and Dictys and Benoit's Roman de Troie, which Herbort von Fritzlar put into German: the Argonauts and the first sack, Paris' judgment as a dream, the love of Troilus and Briseida, Achilles killed for love of Polyxena, the Palladium stolen by Antenor, and Ulysses killed by his son by Circe. The Trojan diaspora then supplies the origin of Romans, Franks, Britons and even, for Snorri, the Æsir.

  1. Jason, Hercules and the first destruction of Troy

    Hercules and Jason put in at Troy on their way to Colchis and are insulted by King Laomedon. Medea, learned in medicine and the 'black book' of necromancy, gives Jason a ring against sorcery, the dragon and fire; returning, Hercules cuts off Laomedon's head and Telamon carries off Priam's sister Hesione.

    Where the sources differ. Herbort cites Dares as his authority (1617). In Greek myth Hercules sacks Troy over Laomedon's unpaid reward for saving Hesione from a sea monster, not on the Argonautic voyage. Dante (Inf. 18.86-96) punishes Jason for abandoning Hypsipyle and Medea.

    Place: Troy

    Sources. Herbort 340-351 ↗ EN Herbort 550-565 ↗ EN Herbort 1544-1617 ↗ EN

  2. Paris' dream and Helen

    Paris tells how, cooling himself at a spring, he saw Venus, Pallas and Juno with a golden apple, each offering a gift if he named her fairest: Juno riches, Pallas skill, Venus the fairest woman. Helen, wife of the Greek king, is the reward Venus promised.

    Where the sources differ. The judgment becomes a dream vision, as in Dares; the Faust Book (ch. 45) gives Helen's ancestry as daughter of Tyndareus and Leda, sister of Castor and Pollux.

    Place: Troy

    Sources. Herbort 2190-2209 ↗ EN Herbort 2398-2405 ↗ EN

  3. Troilus and Briseida

    Calchas, gone over to the Greeks, asks for his daughter Briseida (first called Briseis); she parts in grief from Troilus, and in the Greek camp gives her love to Diomedes, who carries her sleeve as a banner. Troilus fights on as a second Hector until Achilles kills him.

    Where the sources differ. Herbort's Briseida (after Benoit) becomes Boccaccio's Criseida, Chaucer's Criseyde and Shakespeare's Cressida, with Pandarus the go-between; Homer has only Briseis, Achilles' captive, and a Troilus killed before the Iliad begins.

    Place: Troy

    Sources. Herbort 8144-8151 ↗ EN Herbort 8539-8547 ↗ EN Herbort 9880-9887 ↗ EN Troilus and Cressida 3.2.124 ↗

  4. Hector's death and Achilles' love

    Achilles kills Hector and prays for his soul. Later, mad for love of Priam's daughter Polyxena, he is lured with Antilochus into a temple by Hector's tomb, where Paris and twenty knights, at Hecuba's plotting, cut him down.

    Where the sources differ. Dante places Achilles among the lustful as one 'who fought with love at the end', following this medieval story; the ancient sources give his death to Paris' arrow guided by Apollo.

    Place: Troy

    Sources. Herbort 10396-10448 ↗ EN Herbort 11260-11266 ↗ EN Herbort 13536-13663 ↗ EN Inf. 5.65-66 ↗ EN

  5. The Palladium and the horse

    Pallas sent the Palladium to Troy, and the city cannot fall while it is kept; the traitor Antenor bribes the priest Theanus and steals it for Ulysses, and the horse is built. Aeneas and Antenor survive the sack.

    Where the sources differ. In Herbort Antenor (with Aeneas) betrays the city; in Virgil Ulysses and Diomedes take the Palladium themselves, and Dante punishes them for it and for the horse.

    Place: Troy

    Sources. Herbort 15628-15637 ↗ EN Herbort 15840-15849 ↗ EN Inf. 26.58-63 ↗ EN

  6. The death of Ulysses

    Herbort ends with Ulysses killed at his own gate by Telegonus, his unknown son by Circe; Dante's Ulysses instead leaves Circe, sails past the Pillars of Hercules to 'follow virtue and knowledge', and drowns in sight of the mountain of Purgatory.

    Where the sources differ. Two medieval endings against Homer's prophecy of a gentle death 'away from the sea': Herbort follows the Telegony through Benoit; Dante invents (or takes from a lost tradition) the last voyage.

    Place: Pillars of Hercules

    Sources. Herbort 18274-18442 ↗ EN Inf. 26.90-142 ↗ EN

  7. New Troys: Rome, Xanten, London and Asgard

    The survivors found nations: Aeneas wins Italy and builds Alba, whence Rome; Antenor founds Padua; Franko builds 'a little Troy' at Xanten on the Rhine; Brute, Aeneas' descendant, guided by Diana's oracle, founds Troinouant, 'new Troy', in Britain; and Snorri's Odin leads the men of Asia north from Troy.

    Where the sources differ. Holinshed gives two lines for Brute's father (through Creusa's Ascanius or Lavinia's Posthumus) and will not choose; Xanten, Siegfried's birthplace in the Nibelungenlied, is the Franks' little Troy in the Annolied.

    Place: Troy

    Sources. Annolied 22.1-23.26 ↗ EN Holinshed, England 2.1.4 ↗ Holinshed, England 2.2.1 ↗ Holinshed, England 2.4.2 ↗ Prologue 6.21-6.23 ↗ EN

  8. Helen raised from the dead

    In the English Faust Book (1592) Faustus conjures 'fayre Helena of Greece, for whom the worthy towne of Troje was destroyed' for his students, and later takes her spirit as paramour; she bears him a son who vanishes with her at his death.

    Where the sources differ. The Faust Book says the devil 'blindeth' the students with lust (3.45.3); the Helen is a demon in her shape, as Augustine had said of all such apparitions (Civ. 18.18).

    Sources. English Faust Book ch. 45 ↗ English Faust Book ch. 55 ↗ English Faust Book ch. 63 ↗

Everyone in this myth

Follow the myths on the map in the interactive atlas