Horus and Seth: The Contest for the Throne
The war between Osiris's son and his murderer is the political half of the Osiris myth: who inherits Egypt. The Pyramid Texts treat it as a settled lawsuit — Horus's eye and Seth's testicles, the verdict of Geb and the gods at Heliopolis, Seth set beneath Osiris — while Plutarch tells it as a war and a trial of legitimacy, with Thoth as Horus's advocate.
Conception
Isis comes to the dead Osiris 'rejoicing for love of you'; his seed enters her 'sharp as Sothis', and Horus-Sopdu comes forth from him as 'Horus who is in Sothis'.
Where the sources differ. Plutarch distinguishes this posthumous child — Harpocrates, born premature and weak in the legs (De Is. 19) — from the elder Horus, Arueris, whom Isis and Osiris conceived while still in their mother's womb (De Is. 12, 54).
Sources. PT 366 §632a (Teti) ↗ EN PT 366 §632b-c (Teti) ↗ PT 366 §632d (Teti) ↗ EN Plut. De Is. 19 ↗
Hidden in the marshes
Typhon searches everywhere for Osiris's son. At Buto, seat of Egypt's most honoured oracle, the goddess Leto takes the child from Isis and hides him on an island said to float; Plutarch says he was reared by Leto in the Buto marshes.
Where the sources differ. Herodotus makes Apollo (Horus) and Artemis (Bubastis) both children of Dionysus (Osiris) and Isis, with Leto as nurse, and says Aeschylus took from this story his making Artemis a daughter of Demeter (Hdt. 2.156.5–6).
Place: Buto
Training for vengeance
Osiris returns from Hades to train his son and asks which animal is most useful in battle. Horus answers the horse, because a lion helps the one in need but a horse cuts down the fleeing enemy, and Osiris knows he is ready. Many go over to Horus, among them Typhon's concubine Thoueris.
Where the sources differ. Only Plutarch; the Pyramid Texts have no training scene.
Sources. Plut. De Is. 19 ↗
The eye and the testicles
In the struggle Horus is wounded in his eye and Seth in his testicles: 'Horus fell because of his eye, Seth suffered because of his testicles'. A fragmentary serpent spell of Pepi I has each god's seed go into the other, perhaps the first trace of their sexual contest. Horus takes his eye back from Seth and gives it to Osiris, and every offering becomes 'the Eye of Horus' — even 'the little eye of Horus, which Seth ate'.
Where the sources differ. Plutarch reads the injury as astronomy: Typhon now strikes and now swallows the eye of Horus and gives it back to the sun — the moon's waning and eclipse (De Is. 55); a statue at Coptos shows Horus holding Typhon's genitals (De Is. 55).
Sources. PT 359 §594a (Teti) ↗ EN PT 386 §679d (Teti) ↗ EN PT 501C §5-6 (Pepi I) ↗ PT 215 §142a (Unas) ↗ EN PT 215 §142b (Unas) ↗ EN PT 145 §88c-d (Unas) ↗ PT 357 §591b.1 (Teti) ↗ EN Plut. De Is. 55 ↗
Isis frees Seth
After a battle of many days Horus wins and Typhon is handed over to Isis in chains — but she releases him. Horus, enraged, tears the royal crown from his mother's head, and Hermes gives her a cow-headed helmet instead.
Where the sources differ. Plutarch leaves out, as too shocking, 'the dismemberment of Horus and the beheading of Isis' (De Is. 20). Diodorus has the opposite ending: Isis, helped by Horus, kills Typhon and his accomplices and rules Egypt (Diod. 1.21.3), or punishes him — whence red oxen, and once red-haired men, were sacrificed at Osiris's tomb because Typhon was red (Diod. 1.88.4–5).
Sources. Plut. De Is. 19 ↗ Plut. De Is. 20 ↗ Diod. 1.21.3 ↗ EN Diod. 1.88.4 ↗ EN
The tribunal
Typhon sues Horus for illegitimacy; with Hermes (Thoth) as advocate Horus is judged legitimate by the gods, and Typhon is beaten in two further battles. In the Pyramid Texts the case is heard 'in the Mansion of the Prince in Heliopolis': Geb's word and the gods' threat condemn Seth for striking Osiris to the earth, and Seth is placed beneath Osiris to carry him.
Where the sources differ. In the PT trial Seth's own excuses give Osiris new names, 'Earth-attacker' and Orion (PT 477 §957–959). Plutarch's allegory turns the bastardy suit into matter's imperfection: Horus is not pure like his father, but Hermes, reason, proves him true (De Is. 54).
Place: Heliopolis
Sources. Plut. De Is. 19 ↗ PT 477 §957a-959e (Pepi I) ↗ EN PT 485 §1027a-1028a (Pepi I) ↗ PT 356 §581a-b (Teti) ↗ Plut. De Is. 54 ↗
Horus inherits
Horus becomes king of Egypt — in Herodotus the last of the gods to rule before men, in Diodorus the last god to reign after Osiris left mankind — while the gods' domains are shared as 'the Mounds of Horus and the Mounds of Seth'.
Where the sources differ. Diodorus adds that the Titans had killed Horus and Isis raised him with her drug of immortality, teaching him medicine and divination (Diod. 1.25.6–7).
Place: Egypt
Sources. Hdt. 2.144.2 ↗ Diod. 1.25.7 ↗ EN PT 477 §961a-c (Pepi I) ↗ Diod. 1.25.6 ↗ EN