The Geography of the Underworld
Assembles the Greek and Roman land of the dead from its sources, in the order a traveller meets it. Homer's dead lie across Ocean; Hesiod adds the hound and the Styx; Plato turns the rivers into a hydraulic system; Virgil builds the full map of vestibule, ferry, judges, Tartarus, Elysium and Lethe. Real rivers and caves (Acheron in Thesprotia, Styx at Nonacris, Taenarum, Avernus) were shown as its entrances, and those are the only parts given coordinates.
The way in
Homer's road to the dead runs by ship across Ocean to a level shore with Persephone's groves of poplar and willow, in the sunless land of the Cimmerians; Hermes leads souls past the White Rock and the gates of the Sun.
Where the sources differ. Later sources open land entrances: the cave at Taenarum (Apollod. 2.5.12; doubted by Paus. 3.25.5), the cave by Avernus near Cumae (Aen. 6.126, 6.237-242), and Pausanias thought Homer's rivers were named from the real Acheron and Cocytus of Thesprotia (1.17.5).
Place: Oceanus
Sources. Hom. Od. 10.508 ↗ Hom. Od. 10.509 ↗ Hom. Od. 11.14 ↗ Hom. Od. 24.11 ↗ Hom. Od. 24.12 ↗
The threshold and its monsters
Before the halls of Hades a terrible hound fawns on those who enter but devours any who try to leave; Virgil fills the vestibule with Grief, Disease and Fear, and stables at the doors Centaurs, Scyllas, Briareus, the Hydra, the Chimaera, Gorgons, Harpies and Geryon's shade.
Where the sources differ. Cerberus has fifty heads in Hesiod (Th. 312), three in Apollodorus and Virgil; Hecataeus (in Paus. 3.25.5) made him a snake of Taenarum; Homer never names him.
CerberusThe CentaursScyllaThe Hundred-HandersThe Lernaean HydraThe ChimaeraThe GorgonsThe HarpiesGeryonThe House of HadesPlace: The House of Hades
Sources. Hes. Th. 769 ↗ Hes. Th. 772 ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.273 ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.286 ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.289 ↗
The rivers
Pyriphlegethon (fire) and Cocytus (wailing), a branch of Styx, pour into Acheron at a rock where the two rivers meet.
Where the sources differ. Plato's Phaedo turns them into one hydraulic system: all rivers pour into the chasm of Tartarus and out again; Pyriphlegethon burns and spouts lava on earth, the Stygian river forms the lake Styx, and souls are carried past the Acherusian lake (Phd. 112-114). Virgil's Acheron belches its sand into Cocytus by the Stygian marsh.
Place: The Acheron
Sources. Hom. Od. 10.513 ↗ Hom. Od. 10.514 ↗ Pl. Phd. 113b ↗ Pl. Phd. 113c ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.323 ↗
The ferryman
Charon, an old man with a boat and pole, takes the dead across; Aristophanes' Heracles warns Dionysus of the two-obol fare.
Where the sources differ. Charon is absent from Homer and Hesiod; Pausanias traces Polygnotus' aged Charon to the archaic epic Minyas (10.28.2). Virgil's Charon keeps the waters of both Acheron and Cocytus.
Place: The Acheron
Sources. Eur. Alc. 254 ↗ Ar. Ran. 140 ↗ EN Ar. Ran. 183 ↗ EN Verg. Aen. 6.298 ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.303 ↗
Styx and the oath of the gods
Styx, eldest daughter of Ocean, lives apart in a house pillared with silver; Iris fetches her water in a golden jug when a god must swear, and a perjured god lies breathless for a year and is excluded from the gods for nine more.
Where the sources differ. Homer makes the Titaressus a branch of Styx (Il. 2.751-755); Pausanias identified the water of Styx with a stream falling down a cliff near Nonacris in Arcadia (8.17.6).
Place: The Styx
Sources. Hes. Th. 776 ↗ Hes. Th. 784 ↗ Hes. Th. 805 ↗ Hom. Il. 15.37 ↗
The judges
Minos sits with a golden sceptre giving judgement to the dead; Virgil's Minos shakes the urn and calls the council of the silent.
Where the sources differ. Homer's Minos settles the disputes of the dead and his Rhadamanthys lives in Elysium; Plato makes Minos, Rhadamanthys and Aeacus judges at a crossroads, one road leading to the Isles of the Blessed, the other to Tartarus (Gorg. 524a).
Place: The House of Hades
Sources. Hom. Od. 11.569 ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.432 ↗ Pl. Gorg. 524a ↗
The asphodel meadow
The spirits, 'phantoms of the dead', dwell in the meadow of asphodel; Achilles' shade strides across it, and Hermes leads the suitors' squeaking souls there with his wand.
Where the sources differ. Hermes as guide of souls appears only in Odyssey 24 among Homer's books; Virgil's Mercury uses the wand to call souls from Orcus (Aen. 4.242).
Place: The Asphodel Meadow
Sources. Hom. Od. 11.539 ↗ Hom. Od. 24.2 ↗ Hom. Od. 24.13 ↗ Hom. Od. 24.14 ↗
Tartarus
Below everything lies Tartarus, misty and ringed with bronze and triple night, where the Titans are imprisoned under guard and Night has her house; Virgil walls it three times, rings it with burning Phlegethon and sets Tisiphone at its gate.
Where the sources differ. Its depth is the classic variant: as far below earth as heaven is above (Hesiod; Apollodorus), as far below Hades as heaven is above earth (Il. 8.16), or twice the height of the sky (Aen. 6.578-579).
Place: Tartarus
Sources. Hes. Th. 720 ↗ Hes. Th. 726 ↗ Hom. Il. 8.16 ↗ Apollod. 1.1.2 ↗ Pl. Phd. 112a ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.551 ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.578 ↗
Elysium and the Isles of the Blessed
For a favoured few there is a happier place: Homer's Elysian plain at the ends of the earth with Rhadamanthys, Hesiod's Isles of the Blessed under Kronos, Pindar's island of ocean breezes and golden flowers, Virgil's joyful lawns of the Fortunate Groves.
Where the sources differ. In Homer and Hesiod it is for chosen heroes sent there without dying; in Pindar and Plato it is the reward of the just after judgement; Virgil moves it inside the underworld, on the right-hand road.
Place: Elysium
Sources. Hom. Od. 4.563 ↗ Hes. WD 171 ↗ Pind. Ol. 2.70 ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.639 ↗ Pl. Gorg. 524a ↗
Lethe and return
Before rebirth the souls drink forgetfulness: Plato's souls camp on the burning plain of Lethe and drink from the river Ameles; Virgil's souls owed new bodies drink long oblivion from the river Lethe.
Where the sources differ. In Hesiod Lethe is not a place but a daughter of Strife (Th. 226-227); Homer has no river of forgetting.
Place: Lethe
Sources. Pl. Rep. 621a ↗ Pl. Rep. 621a ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.714 ↗ Verg. Aen. 6.715 ↗