Theseus, Minos and the Minotaur
The Athenian national saga: a hero of double paternity who opens the road to Athens, ends the Cretan tribute, unites Attica and then over-reaches with Pirithous. The Cretan side gives Minos, Pasiphae, Daedalus and the labyrinth. The sources are mostly late (Apollodorus' Epitome, Plutarch), and the most contested point is the fate of Ariadne.
A double conception at Troezen
Childless Aegeus receives a riddling oracle about a wineskin; at Troezen Pittheus makes him drunk and lays him with his daughter Aethra, with whom Poseidon also lies that night. Aegeus leaves a sword and sandals under a rock for his son.
Place: Troezen
The road to Athens
Grown, Theseus lifts the rock, takes the tokens and walks to Athens, killing the brigands who infest the road: Periphetes, Sinis, the Crommyonian sow, Sciron, Cercyon and Damastes (Procrustes).
Where the sources differ. Apollodorus notes that some call Damastes 'Polypemon' (Epit. 1.4).
Place: Athens
Medea at Athens
Medea, now Aegeus' wife, persuades him to send the unknown youth against the Marathonian bull and then to poison him; Aegeus recognizes the sword just in time and Theseus drives Medea out.
Place: Athens
Sources. Apollod. Epit. 1.5 ↗ Apollod. Epit. 1.6 ↗ Apollod. 1.9.28 ↗
Minos, Pasiphae and the tribute
Minos keeps the bull Poseidon sent from the sea; the god makes Pasiphae desire it, Daedalus builds her a wooden cow, and she bears Asterius the Minotaur, whom Minos shuts in Daedalus' labyrinth and feeds with Athenian youths and maidens.
Where the sources differ. Apollodorus (3.15.7-8) also gives the war over Androgeos' death as the cause of the tribute; Ovid has the lot drawn every nine years (Met. 8.169-171).
Place: Knossos
Sources. Apollod. 3.1.3 ↗ Apollod. 3.1.4 ↗ Apollod. 3.15.8 ↗
The thread and the labyrinth
Theseus goes to Crete with the tribute; Ariadne, in love, gets the secret of the exit from Daedalus and gives Theseus a thread; he kills the Minotaur with his fists and finds his way out.
Where the sources differ. Plutarch reports the thread version as what 'most write and sing' (Thes. 19.1).
Place: Knossos
Sources. Apollod. Epit. 1.8 ↗ Apollod. Epit. 1.9 ↗ Ov. Met. 8.169-171 ↗
Ariadne's fate and the black sail
Theseus sails off with Ariadne but loses her; grieving, he forgets to hoist the white sail, and Aegeus, seeing the black one from the acropolis, throws himself down. Theseus becomes king.
Where the sources differ. The library preserves at least four endings: Dionysus carries her off from Naxos (Apollod. Epit. 1.9); Artemis kills her on Dia on Dionysus' testimony (Od. 11.324-325); Theseus abandons her on Dia (Catull. 64.52-54); she hangs herself when deserted (Plut. Thes. 20.1).
Sources. Apollod. Epit. 1.9 ↗ Od. 11.324-325 ↗ Catull. 64.52-54 ↗ Plut. Thes. 20.1 ↗ Apollod. Epit. 1.10 ↗
Amazons, Phaedra and Hippolytus
With Heracles Theseus carries off an Amazon, defeats the Amazon army at the Areopagus and has a son, Hippolytus; later he marries Minos' daughter Phaedra, who falls for her stepson and accuses him falsely, and Poseidon's bull kills Hippolytus at Theseus' prayer.
Where the sources differ. The Amazon is Antiope, Melanippe or (Simonides) Hippolyte (Epit. 1.16); she dies attacking Phaedra's wedding, by Theseus' hand or by Penthesilea's (Epit. 1.17, 5.2).
Place: Athens
Sources. Apollod. Epit. 1.16 ↗ Apollod. Epit. 1.17 ↗ Apollod. Epit. 1.18 ↗ Apollod. Epit. 1.19 ↗
Helen, Hades and death on Scyros
With Pirithous Theseus carries off the twelve-year-old Helen and goes down to Hades to win Persephone for his friend; both are trapped on the Seat of Forgetfulness until Heracles frees Theseus alone. Meanwhile the Dioscuri retake Helen; driven out of Athens, Theseus is killed by Lycomedes on Scyros.
Where the sources differ. Plutarch reports a claim that the Odyssey's line naming Theseus and Pirithous among the dead (11.631) was inserted by Peisistratus to please the Athenians (Thes. 20.2).
Place: The House of Hades
Sources. Apollod. Epit. 1.23 ↗ Apollod. Epit. 1.24 ↗ Plut. Thes. 35.4 ↗