Demeter and Persephone
The Homeric Hymn to Demeter's story of the abduction of Persephone by Hades, Demeter's search and grief, her nursing of Demophon at Eleusis, the famine that forces Zeus to relent, the pomegranate seed that binds Persephone to spend part of every year below, and the founding of the Eleusinian Mysteries. Apollodorus, Pausanias, Ovid and Cicero relocate and re-cast many details.
The abduction
Persephone is picking flowers with the daughters of Ocean when Earth, by Zeus' plan, sends up a wondrous hundred-headed narcissus. As she reaches for it the earth gapes on the Nysian plain and Hades, Kronos' son, carries her off in his golden chariot; only Hecate in her cave and Helios hear her cry.
Where the sources differ. Hesiod has Zeus give her to Aidoneus (Th. 913-914). The place moves: the Nysian plain in the Hymn; Lerna, where Argives showed the spot Pluto descended (Paus. 2.36.7); and Sicilian Henna in Cicero (Verr. 2.4.106) and Ovid (Met. 5.385-391; Fast. 4.422). Apollodorus makes her the daughter of Zeus and Styx (1.3.1), though he too calls Demeter her mother in the abduction (1.5.1).
Place: Nysa
Sources. Hom. Hymn Dem. 2 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 8 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 17 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 19 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 25 ↗ Hes. Th. 913 ↗
The search
For nine days Demeter roams the earth with burning torches, tasting neither ambrosia nor nectar. On the tenth Hecate meets her carrying a light, and together they go to Helios, who tells her that Zeus gave her daughter to his brother Hades as wife.
Where the sources differ. Apollodorus (1.5.1) has her learn the truth from the people of Hermione. In Arcadia (Paus. 8.25.5) Poseidon pursues her during the search; she turns into a mare, he into a stallion, and she becomes Demeter Erinys in her wrath.
Sources. Hom. Hymn Dem. 47 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 52 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 62 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 78 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 79 ↗
At Eleusis
In anger Demeter leaves Olympus and, in the form of an old woman, sits by the Maiden Well at Eleusis, where the daughters of Celeus find her. In the house she sits silent and unsmiling until the servant Iambe's jokes make her laugh; she refuses red wine and asks for barley-meal and water.
Where the sources differ. Apollodorus places her first on the Laughless Rock beside the Callichoron well and makes Iambe the origin of the ritual jesting of the Thesmophoria (1.5.1); Pausanias saw the Callichoron well where Eleusinian women first danced for her (1.38.6).
Place: Eleusis
Sources. Hom. Hymn Dem. 96 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 98 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 200 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 202 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 208 ↗
Demophon in the fire
As nurse to Metaneira's baby Demophon, Demeter anoints him with ambrosia by day and hides him in the fire by night, so that he grows like a god; she would have made him ageless and deathless had Metaneira not spied on her and screamed. The goddess angrily drops the child, reveals herself and foretells eternal war-games among the Eleusinians.
Where the sources differ. In Apollodorus (1.5.1-2) the watcher is Praxithea and the baby is consumed by the fire; the eldest son, Triptolemus, receives the consolation gift of grain instead.
Place: Eleusis
Sources. Hom. Hymn Dem. 234 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 239 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 243 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 248 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 260 ↗
Temple and famine
Demeter orders the people to build her a great temple and altar above the Callichorus well, then sits in it apart from the gods, wasting with longing. She makes a terrible year: the earth sends up no seed, oxen drag ploughs in vain, and mankind and the gods' sacrifices would have perished.
Where the sources differ. Only the Hymn tells the famine so fully. Ovid's Ceres, finding Proserpina's girdle, breaks the ploughs of Sicily and makes the seed fail (Met. 5.477-482).
Place: Eleusis
Sources. Hom. Hymn Dem. 270 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 272 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 305 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 307 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 310 ↗
Hermes in the house of Hades
Zeus sends Hermes down to Erebus to bring Persephone up. Hades obeys, but secretly gives her a honey-sweet pomegranate seed to eat, so she will not stay for ever above with her mother.
Where the sources differ. Apollodorus (1.5.3) adds that Ascalaphus, son of Acheron, bore witness against her, and Demeter punished him with a heavy rock in Hades. Ovid has her pluck the pomegranate herself in Pluto's garden (Met. 5.536).
Place: The House of Hades
Sources. Hom. Hymn Dem. 335 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 340 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 347 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 372 ↗
Reunion and the third of the year
Mother and daughter embrace at Eleusis; Demeter asks whether she ate anything below, for if she did she must dwell a third of the seasons under the earth and two with the gods, rising each spring when the earth blooms. Hecate becomes Persephone's attendant, and Rhea brings Zeus' promise of honours.
Where the sources differ. A third of the year in the Hymn and in Apollodorus (1.5.3); half the year, six months with each, in Ovid (Met. 5.564-567). Cicero, following the Stoics, reads Proserpina as the seed of grain hidden and sought by her mother (Nat. D. 2.66).
Place: Eleusis
Sources. Hom. Hymn Dem. 393 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 398 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 399 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 401 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 440 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 442 ↗
The Mysteries and Triptolemus
Demeter makes the fields bear again and shows her rites to Triptolemus, Diocles, Eumolpus and Celeus: awful mysteries that may not be spoken. Blessed is the mortal who has seen them; the uninitiated has no like share after death.
Where the sources differ. Apollodorus has Demeter give Triptolemus wheat and a chariot of winged dragons to sow the inhabited world, and notes rival parentages: Panyasis makes him son of Eleusis, Pherecydes of Oceanus and Ge (1.5.2). Pausanias adds Argive, Athenian, Musaean and Orphic versions (1.14.2-3) and saw Triptolemus' temple, threshing floor and the Rharian plain at Eleusis (1.38.6).
Place: Eleusis
Sources. Hom. Hymn Dem. 471 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 474 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 476 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 480 ↗ Hom. Hymn Dem. 482 ↗
Arcadian Demeters
Arcadians told a darker variant: during the search Poseidon desired Demeter, she became a mare among the herds of Oncius, and he mated with her as a stallion. She raged, then washed her anger off in the Ladon, so Thelpusa worshipped her as Erinys and Lousia; at Phigalia her cave-image was the Black Demeter.
Where the sources differ. At Thelpusa the offspring was the horse Arion and a daughter whose name may not be told to the uninitiated (8.25.7); at Phigalia not a horse but the goddess the Arcadians call Despoina (8.42.1). Herodotus equates Demeter with Isis (2.59, 2.156), and Cicero derives Demeter from ge meter, Earth-mother (Nat. D. 2.67).
Place: Thelpusa
Sources. Paus. 8.25.4 ↗ Paus. 8.25.5 ↗ Paus. 8.25.6 ↗ Paus. 8.42.1 ↗