Atlantis
The only Atlantis in the library is Plato's: told in the Timaeus as an Egyptian priest's record handed to Solon, and elaborated in the unfinished Critias. Nothing earlier mentions it. Strabo shows that ancient readers already argued over whether it was history, with Posidonius willing to believe it, against a view (which modern scholars usually trace to Aristotle) that its inventor sank it, as Homer did the Achaean wall.
The source: Sais
Critias tells a story his family had from Solon, who heard it from priests at Sais in the Egyptian Delta, a city whose goddess is Neith, 'in Greek, Athena'.
Where the sources differ. No earlier text in the library knows the story; the chain of transmission is Plato's own frame.
Sources. Pl. Tim. 21e ↗
Poseidon and Cleito
When the gods divided the earth, Poseidon received Atlantis. He fell in love with Cleito, the orphaned daughter of an earth-born couple, and fenced her hill with alternate rings of sea and land, two of land and three of sea, bringing up hot and cold springs.
Place: Atlantis
Sources. Pl. Criti. 113c ↗ Pl. Criti. 113d ↗ Pl. Criti. 113d ↗ Pl. Criti. 113d ↗
The ten kings
Poseidon fathered five pairs of twins and divided the island into ten parts; the eldest, Atlas, was king over the rest and gave his name to the island and the Atlantic sea.
Where the sources differ. Plato's Atlas is a son of Poseidon and a mortal, not the Titan who holds up the sky; Gadeirus, his twin, is linked to Gadeira (Cadiz).
Place: Atlantis
Orichalc and Poseidon's pillar
The kings walled the rings in bronze, tin and fire-gleaming orichalc, kept a gold-fenced shrine of Cleito and Poseidon at the centre, and ruled by laws inscribed on an orichalc pillar in Poseidon's temple.
Place: Atlantis
Sources. Pl. Criti. 116c ↗ Pl. Criti. 116c ↗ Pl. Criti. 119c ↗
Empire and war
From beyond the Pillars of Heracles the kings ruled Libya to Egypt and Europe to Tyrrhenia, and nine thousand years before Solon marched on the rest; ancient Athens led the resistance and defeated them.
Place: The Pillars of Heracles
Sources. Pl. Tim. 24e ↗ Pl. Tim. 24e ↗ Pl. Tim. 25a ↗ Pl. Tim. 25b ↗ Pl. Criti. 108e ↗
The sinking
In one terrible day and night of earthquakes and floods Athens' army was swallowed by the earth and Atlantis sank into the sea, leaving a shoal of mud that blocks the open sea.
Place: Atlantis
Zeus' judgement
As the divine element in the kings faded and they grew greedy, Zeus, who reigns by law, gathered all the gods in his most honoured dwelling to punish them, and began to speak.
Where the sources differ. The Critias breaks off mid-sentence here; the punishment is known only from the Timaeus' account of the sinking.
Sources. Pl. Criti. 121b ↗ Pl. Criti. 121b ↗ Pl. Criti. 121c ↗
Fact or fiction?
Strabo reports that Posidonius thought the story might not be an invention, and preferred that to the view that its inventor had made it vanish, as Homer did the Achaean wall.
Where the sources differ. The ancient debate itself is the last episode of the myth in this library.